Summary (from
Goodreads):
If you love holiday stories, holiday movies,
made-for-TV-holiday specials, holiday episodes of your favorite sitcoms and,
especially, if you love holiday anthologies, you’re going to fall in love with
MY TRUE LOVE GAVE TO ME: TWELVE HOLIDAY STORIES by twelve bestselling young
adult writers, edited by international bestselling author Stephanie Perkins.
Review:
This was one of those books I had to get immediately, the
day it was published. I love YA short story anthologies. I also love so many of
the YA authors who contributed to this, not to mention Stephanie Perkins put it
together! However, I’m not always
the biggest holiday story person. It’s hard growing up and not seeing special
Chanukah episodes of your favorite shows. That, and the whole Santa/elf thing
always seemed so silly to me (and I’m a Children’s librarian –big advocate of
the silly). I just find it weird that there are so many adult holiday stories
that involve Santa…I was super excited the day after Christmas because I could
turn on the radio and have normal music back. All that aside, I had a feeling
I’d love this book.
I think what I loved the most about this particular
anthology was that it was unconventional. It wasn’t all about Christmas. There
even was one Chanukah story! There was one story about a girl who celebrated
Winter Solstice. Another story was all about New Year’s Eve. And yes, there was
still a lot of Christmas. But even the Christmas stories themselves tended be
more modern and unconventional. So, I was pleased overall!
Since each story was so different, and written by a
different author, I thought (like most other reviewers) I’d review and rate
each story (maybe just a few sentences about each because there are a lot).
Midnights by Rainbow Rowell
So, more often then not in these types of collections, I’m surprised by not
liking the ones I think I’ll like the most and then loving the stories I had no
idea I’d love. And while this did happen in this book, it did not happen with
this story. I thought I’d love it, and I did! I think it may have been my
favorite story in the whole thing. Rowell just is so good at capturing first
love, crushes, awkward moments, and dialog. And just Wow, this started the
whole book with a Bang. (10/10)
The Lady and the Fox
by Kelly Link
I’ve only really read this author in these kinds of
collections before. And she’s always hit or miss with me. This one started off
good. But then it got weird, and then the ending was rushed. It’s like she was
given a page limit and had to somehow end things in a limited amount of time.
It was a little confusing and while I loved the beginning, overall I was
disappointed. (7/10)
Angels in the Snow by
Matt De La Pena
I don’t believe I’ve read this author before (the only one I
can say this about), and I wasn’t expecting to love it. But, I did! What a
surprise. I loved that the two characters were so different. I’m not sure I ever read anything YA
where the main character was struggling so much economically that they were
physically hungry. I loved the NYC setting. The girl wasn’t quite as
believable/likeable for me as the guy, but I still loved it. (9/10).
Polaris is Where
You’ll Find Me by Jenny Han
This one wasn’t my favorite. Besides the whole “why are
adults/teens supposed to go for the Santa thing” concept that I kind of
mentioned not liking before, I feel like this had really good potential for
being awesome. It was the only story to involve elves. I liked the idea of the
girl being different amongst a world of elves. There was just so much I wasn’t
feeling/believing about the guy, about her “friends,” and about her family
situation. (6/10)
It’s a Yuletide
Miracle, Charlie Brown by Stephanie Perkins
This probably makes a close second place for the Rainbow
Rowell one. And I was afraid the authors I loved the most would have meh
stories. This one was adorable. I liked having a character who celebrated the
Winter Solstice and science. I liked the long-lasting crush, the interest in
animation, and all the awkward conversation. Also, I’m still swooning over the
guy. Don’t ever stop writing, Stephanie Perkins. (10/10)
Your Temporary Santa
by David Levithan
Yay for an LGBT story! I really enjoyed this one too. I
thought the concept of doing anything for the person you’re starting to date is
so spot-on. This story captures that moment when you’re in a relationship and
you realize you might actually being falling harder than you thought. But, more
than that, it was also about family and doing something nice for someone who
needed nice. (9/10)
Krampuslauf by Holly
Black
This was a weird one. I either love Holly Black’s stuff or I
don’t. And I guess I loved this one. There were some definite magic/fantasy
elements going on here. And I loved the combination of contemporary with the magic.
I thought the party, the economic divide, the boyfriend drama with the main
character’s friend, were all so believable. So, when the magic happens, it was
a surprise, and just well executed. (9/10)
What the Hell Have
You Done, Sophie Roth? By Gayle Forman
I also either love or hate this author’s work. And I ended
up loving her story. Yay for a Jewish story! Also, yay for an interracial love
story! I super connected to the main character’s rural adaptations. I also went
from a big city to a rural college, and understood a lot of her
melancholy. I loved the diner
scene. Though, the one thing I didn’t love was the resolution. I felt like the
main character accomplished a little too much in one night/one story to be
believable. Short stories don’t always have to have such an ending. (8/10)
Beer Buckets and Baby
Jesus by Myra McEntire
This was my least favorite story. I love this author’s
books, but I just wasn’t feeling this one. This one also tried to accomplish
too much. Short stories don’t have to have such strong conclusions. Also, I
don’t like how much the main character had to be explained. His rash behavior
was analyzed and talked about. And I guess I’d rather see his behavior and then
make up my own mind for why he was acting the way he was, no explanations
needed. (6/10)
Welcome to Christmas,
CA by Kiersten White
This was a fun one! I loved the magical realism in here.
Also, loved the food elements. I liked that this one was as much about family
as it as about love. And I liked all the twists the main character went through
in discovering the love of her family. (9/10)
Star of Bethlehem by
Ally Carter
I read this one super fast. It wasn’t my favorite. I guess
it was more what I was expecting all the stories to be. It was super adorable
and a little bit ABC Family Christmas movie cheesy, but in a good way. The
situation just seemed so unbelievable. However, I loved loved loved the
relationship that grew in this story. (9/10)
The Girl who Woke the
Dreamer by Laini Taylor
I was expecting to like this one a little bit more. All the
other reviewers have raved about it. While, I got lost in Taylor’s wonderful
writing style (and it was nice to see her writing style with a totally
different story/world), I never really felt the romance. I liked that it was
dark. The world and customs of this world were super interesting. I just never
got a chance to fall for the dreamer, let alone really understand him. His
explanation didn’t make sense to me and there was a lot of vague stuff going
on. It just felt like the author needed more time/more pages to say what she
really wanted to. (8/10).
Overall, I give the anthology a 9/10. I enjoyed it. I
enjoyed being surprised by the unconventional holiday stories. And I’m glad
only one story involved Santa.